Timed Out in Cricket: First-Class and Men’s International Cases, From Heygate in 1919 to Shakeel in 2025
Angelo Mathews was given out without facing a ball at the 2023 World Cup. He was one of a very short list. Here are the first-class and men's international cases, from a disputed ruling at Taunton in 1919 to Rawalpindi in 2025.
By Jozaf · 16 Nov 2026 · 5 min read
On 6 November 2023, at the Arun Jaitley Stadium in Delhi, Angelo Mathews walked out to bat for Sri Lanka against Bangladesh at the men's World Cup and was sent back without facing a ball. He became the first batter in international cricket to be dismissed timed out. The decision divided opinion, but it was not the first of its kind, and this piece follows the recorded cases that came before and after it.
For context, Law 40 requires an incoming batter to be ready to receive the ball within three minutes of a wicket falling, and the fielding side must appeal. ICC playing conditions shorten the limit to two minutes in Tests and one-day internationals and 90 seconds in Twenty20 internationals, which is why the clock at the 2023 World Cup ran for two minutes.
A time limit older than the label
The idea of a deadline for the next batter is much older than the scorecard entry. In May 1919, Sussex played Somerset at Taunton. Short of a player, Sussex pressed Harold Heygate into service from among the spectators, although he carried war wounds to his legs. When he was needed to bat, he did not reach the crease in time; the umpire ruled him out on appeal, the Sussex innings ended, and the match finished as a tie. The scorers wrote him down as ‘out, absent’, and later scorecards list him as absent rather than timed out.
Heygate is not on the list of timed-out cases. The ruling looked very like a timed-out dismissal, but his scorecard entry has never read ‘timed out’.
Seven first-class cases
Before Mathews, MCC counted six timed-out dismissals in the whole of first-class cricket. A seventh followed in March 2025, and seven was still the first-class total as of November 2026. The list is short enough to give in full:
- Andrew Jordaan, Eastern Province v Transvaal, Port Elizabeth, February 1988. After a night of heavy rain, waterlogged roads kept him from the ground. It was a Howa Bowl match, and that competition gained first-class status only years afterwards, so the earliest case on the list was added long after the event.
- Hemulal Yadav, Tripura v Orissa, Cuttack, December 1997. Tripura’s No. 11 never left the boundary, where he was talking to the team manager after the ninth wicket fell.
- Vasbert Drakes, Border v Free State, East London, September 2002. He had been playing for West Indies at the Champions Trophy in Sri Lanka, his flight from Colombo was delayed, and he was still travelling when his turn came. Border lost.
- Andrew Harris, Nottinghamshire v Durham UCCE, Trent Bridge, April 2003. Carrying a groin strain and not expecting to bat, he failed to reach the crease in time, leaving Chris Read stranded on 94 not out. Nottinghamshire still won.
- Ryan Austin, Combined Campuses and Colleges v Windward Islands, Kingstown, 2014. He was not ready in time; his side won the match.
- Charles Kunje, Matabeleland Tuskers v Mountaineers, Bulawayo, December 2017, in the Logan Cup. The Tuskers lost.
- Saud Shakeel, State Bank of Pakistan v Pakistan Television, Rawalpindi, March 2025, in the President’s Trophy final.
Read together, the cases fall into two groups. That is an interpretation, but the facts support it. In some, the batter was simply not at the ground: Jordaan was stopped by the weather and Drakes was still on his way from another continent. In others, the batter was present but not ready: Yadav was distracted on the boundary, Harris was injured, and Shakeel, as described below, came in during a burst of quick wickets. The law treats both groups the same way, because it measures readiness, not intention.
Delhi, 6 November 2023
Sadeera Samarawickrama was dismissed by Shakib Al Hasan in the 25th over of Sri Lanka's innings. Mathews came out, and as he prepared to face, the chin strap on his helmet broke. He signalled to the dressing room for a replacement. Shakib, captaining Bangladesh, appealed and did not withdraw the appeal when Mathews protested, and the on-field umpires gave him out.
MCC set out a timeline in a statement on 10 November 2023. The helmet failed 1 minute 54 seconds after the previous wicket; Mathews had taken more than 90 seconds to reach the 30-yard circle; more than two minutes had passed by the time of the appeal; and he had not begun to take guard. MCC concluded that the umpires were correct. It added that the right course would have been to tell the umpires about the broken helmet and ask for time to fix it, in which case they might have called Time and stopped the clock.
Sri Lanka were bowled out for 279, with Charith Asalanka making a century, and Bangladesh won by three wickets. Afterwards Mathews called Bangladesh’s appeal ‘disgraceful’. On the wider argument, MCC said the Spirit of Cricket is open to interpretation and that players are not required to withdraw appeals.
Near misses and the appeal
The dismissal needs an appeal, and not every delay has produced one. In a Test at Cape Town in 2007, Sachin Tendulkar was not eligible to bat at the moment India needed their next batter, and Sourav Ganguly, who went in instead, was slow to get ready. South Africa did not appeal and Ganguly was allowed to bat; accounts differ on why no appeal was made.
After Delhi
The precedent did not stay isolated for long. In December 2023, at Benoni in South Africa, Ghana’s Godfred Bakiweyem was timed out against Sierra Leone in the Africa Cup T20I competition, the first such dismissal in a Twenty20 international. Ghana won anyway, in a match that also featured an obstructing-the-field dismissal.
In March 2025, in the President’s Trophy final at Rawalpindi, Mohammad Shahzad took wickets with consecutive balls against State Bank of Pakistan. Saud Shakeel, the next man in, did not arrive in time; Pakistan Television appealed and he was given out. Shahzad took another wicket with the next ball to complete a hat-trick. Shakeel became the seventh batter timed out in first-class cricket and the first Pakistani.
What the cases ask of a batter
The following is our reading of the cases rather than anything the Laws spell out. The batters who were caught were rarely lazy. They were injured, stranded, distracted or let down by kit. The common thread is that the clock starts when the previous batter is out, not when the next one feels ready. A batter who is next in should be padded, gloved and helmeted before the wicket falls, should check equipment before leaving the dressing room, and, if something breaks on the way, should tell the umpire at once. Mathews’s case shows that the last step is the one that matters most: Time called by an umpire is the only thing that stops the count.
Frequently asked questions
How long does an incoming batter have before being timed out?
Three minutes under Law 40 of the Laws of Cricket. ICC playing conditions shorten this to two minutes in Tests and one-day internationals and 90 seconds in Twenty20 internationals.
Who was the first batter timed out in a Twenty20 international?
Ghana's Godfred Bakiweyem, against Sierra Leone at Benoni in December 2023, the month after Angelo Mathews became the first batter timed out in any international match.
Could Angelo Mathews have avoided being timed out in 2023?
MCC said that if he had told the umpires about his broken helmet and asked for time, they might have called Time, which would have stopped the clock. Instead he signalled to the dressing room for a replacement, and more than two minutes had passed when Bangladesh appealed.